
On November 16, a federal judge in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts vacated the Department of Homeland Security’s final rule that would have eliminated and replaced the “duration of status” (D/S) framework for F, J and I visa holders. The court vacated the rule in its entirety, two months after it postponed the rule’s effective date through a preliminary injunction.
The D/S system remains in place. F and J holders will continue to be admitted for as long as they comply with the terms of their programs, not until a fixed end date.
Background
As CUPA-HR reported when the DHS finalized the rule in July, the measure would have ended open-ended admission for F (academic student), J (exchange visitor) and I (foreign media representative) visa holders. F and J holders would instead have been admitted for a fixed period tied to program length and capped at four years. Anyone needing more time would have had to file an extension of stay application with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) before their admission period ran out. The rule also cut the post-completion grace period for F holders from 60 days to 30 days and placed new limits on academic mobility.
The DHS received close to 22,000 comments on the proposal. CUPA-HR joined an ACE-led higher education comment letter highlighting concerns with the rule.
Soon after the final rule was published, the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration and NAFSA: Association of International Educators, along with a coalition of higher education associations and labor organizations, filed a lawsuit challenging the rule under the Administrative Procedures Act (APA).
On September 14, one day before the rule was set to take effect, the court postponed its effective date. It found the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in showing the rule was arbitrary and capricious because the DHS did not properly weigh costs and benefits, did not connect the rule to its stated fraud and national security goals, did not consider less burdensome alternatives, and did not respond adequately to significant comments.
The Court’s Decision
In its ruling, the court adopted its analysis from its September postponement order and ruled for the plaintiffs on the same four grounds listed above. The court also considered two supplemental arguments from the plaintiffs and sided with them on both:
- The DHS ignored the tools it already has in SEVIS. The plaintiffs argued that the Department of Homeland Security should have considered making better use of the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) as an alternative to the rule. The DHS responded that SEVIS is a data-reporting system for schools rather than a system for adjudicating immigration status. The court was not persuaded by the DHS and said that, at a minimum, the department should have weighed SEVIS enhancements against the rule’s costs.
- The limits on academic mobility exceed the DHS’s authority. The plaintiffs argued that rule contradicts the statutory language establishing the F-1 visa classification, specifically the language stating that the F-1 program is open to “bona fide student[s] qualified to pursue a full course of study … who seek[] to enter the United States temporarily and solely for the purpose of pursuing such a course of study.” The Department of Homeland Security responded that it has discretion to define what counts as an appropriate course of study. The court disagreed and held that the DHS may only set conditions of stay that are reasonably related to the purpose of the F-1 program.
The Department of Homeland Security is expected to appeal the decision to vacate the final rule. CUPA-HR will continue to track the litigation and provide updates as the case moves forward.