CUPA-HR will be closed Thursday and Friday in observance of the Thanksgiving holiday.

On November 19, the Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division (WHD) announced a final rule rescinding the Biden administration’s 2024 independent contractor regulation and largely restoring the framework the WHD adopted in 2021, with several modifications. The rule provides guidance for employers, employees and courts on how to determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), and it applies the same test under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSPA). The rule has not yet been published in the Federal Register, but it is set to take effect 60 days after it is published.

Background

The WHD’s position on the classification standard has changed three times in five years. In January 2021, at the close of the first Trump administration, the WHD issued a final rule that grounded the FLSA “economic reality” analysis in five non-exhaustive factors. Two of them were designated “core” factors and given greater weight:

  • The nature and degree of control over the work
  • The individual’s opportunity for profit or loss

The other three factors were the amount of skill the work requires, the degree of permanence of the working relationship, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production. The Biden administration tried to delay and then withdraw the rule, but it took effect in March 2021.

The Biden administration’s WHD then replaced the 2021 rule in January 2024 with a new final rule built around six factors applied under a totality-of-the-circumstances analysis, with no factor weighted above the others. That rule drew multiple legal challenges. In May 2025, the WHD issued a Field Assistance Bulletin announcing it would stop applying the 2024 rule in investigations while it reconsidered the regulation, relying instead on Opinion Letter FLSA2019-6.

On February 26, 2026, the WHD proposed rescinding the 2024 rule and restoring a modified version of the 2021 framework. The comment period closed April 28, and the DOL received more than 16,500 comments. CUPA-HR joined the Independent Work Coalition and 34 other organizations in comments supporting the proposal.

The 2026 Final Rule

The final rule largely adopts the framework the WHD proposed in February, with some changes made in response to the comments it received. As finalized, the rule:

  • Rescinds the 2024 rule and its unweighted totality-of-the-circumstances analysis
  • Restores the two core factors, control over the work (“control factor”) and opportunity for profit or loss, which typically carry more weight than the other factors and generally equal weight with each other; when both point the same way, that is substantially likely to be the correct classification
  • Keeps the three additional factors from the 2021 rule: skill required, permanence of the relationship, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production
  • Retains the proposed clarification that economic dependence does not turn on how much a worker earns or whether the worker has other sources of income
  • Expands the regulatory examples from eight proposed to 14, now grouped by factor (see chart below for examples)
  • Applies a single classification framework across the FLSA, FMLA and MSPA

The most notable change from the proposal tightens the control factor. Both the proposed and final rule state that, under the control factor, requiring a contractor to follow the law, meet health and safety standards, carry insurance, or hit agreed-upon deadlines and quality standards still does not count as control. The final rule adds, though, that a requirement is judged by its “substance and practical operation” rather than the “characterization of its purpose.” The rule explains that detailed instructions on how, when or where work is done can indicate an employment relationship even if framed as a safety or quality control measure.

Until the rule takes effect, the WHD will continue enforcing under the approach in its 2025 Field Assistance Bulletin. CUPA-HR is reviewing the final rule and will keep members informed of further updates.

Comparison of 2026 NPRM and 2026 Final Rule Examples
Example2026 NPRM Proposed Rule2026 Final RuleChange
(b)(1) Owner-Operator Truck DriverLogistics company requires compliance with federally mandated drug and alcohol testing and sets delivery deadlines with incentives and penalties; neither constitutes control.Same fact pattern and application.No change.
NEW (b)(2) Digital Platform Delivery Worker (Employee)Not includedApp gives worker seconds to accept orders with no information on pay, time or order size; low acceptance rates trigger demotion in a rewards program, making multi-apping impossible in practice. Control factor weighs toward employee status.New example addressing the control factor.
NEW (b)(3) Digital Platform Delivery Worker (Independent Contractor)Not includedWorker can decline orders without penalty, multi-app, and sees pay up front. Location monitoring, dynamic pricing, and deactivation for excessive cancellations are not control. Control factor weighs toward contractor status.New example addressing the control factor; states that using technology to run a business is not control over the worker.
NEW (b)(4) Farm Labor Contractor (Employee)Not includedGrower requires seasonal exclusivity, sets crew pay, gives instructions several times a day, and sets the crew’s schedule. Control factor weighs toward employee status.New example addressing the control factor.
NEW (b)(5) Farm Labor Contractor (Independent Contractor)Not includedContractor works for multiple farms, sets his crew’s schedule, and works largely unsupervised. Contractual environmental and quality requirements (pesticide limits, refrigeration) are not control. Control factor weighs toward contractor status.New example addressing the control factor.
(b)(6) App-Based Home Repair WorkerNumbered (b)(2). Worker increases earnings through initiative and equipment investment despite company’s large app investment.Renumbered to (b)(6); application references initiative, investment “or both.”Renumbered; conforming edit to match revised profit or loss factor.
(b)(7) Construction Worker With Food TruckNumbered (b)(3). Hourly construction worker owns separate profitable food truck; outside business not relevant to classification.Renumbered to (b)(7); substantively unchanged.Renumbered only.
NEW (b)(8) Lease-Purchase Truck Driver (Employee)Not includedMotor carrier sets non-negotiable rates the driver doesn’t see before committing; lease offers no realistic path to ownership, so payments are a recurring cost of obtaining work. Profit or loss factor weighs toward employee status.New example addressing the opportunity for profit or loss factor.
NEW (b)(9) Lease-Purchase Truck Driver (Independent Contractor)Not includedDriver negotiates rates before committing, seeks backhauls, and has a lease that actually leads to ownership. Profit or loss factor weighs toward contractor status.New example addressing the opportunity for profit or loss factor.
(c)(1) Roofer Without Specialized SkillNumbered (b)(4). Worker hired with no roofing skills; receives on-the-job training; skill factor weighs toward employee status.Renumbered to (c)(1); substantively unchanged.Moved to new subsection for non-core factors.
(c)(2) Skilled Roofer With Specialized TrainingNumbered (b)(5). Worker brings specialized roofing training; hired based on expertise; skill factor weighs toward contractor status.Renumbered to (c)(2); substantively unchanged.Moved to new subsection for non-core factors.
(c)(3) Seasonal Ski Resort HousekeeperNumbered (b)(6). Returns each winter season without reapplying; permanence factor weighs toward employee status.Renumbered to (c)(3); substantively unchanged.Moved to new subsection for non-core factors.
(c)(4) Part-Time EditorNumbered (b)(7). Newspaper editor assigns, reviews, writes or revises articles; integrated into production process.Renumbered to (c)(4). Editor works from home for a digital news outlet, decides when articles appear on the website, and coordinates with full-time employee editors. Remote work does not outweigh integration.Updated to reflect a digital newsroom; integrated unit factor still weighs toward employee status.
(c)(5) Freelance JournalistNumbered (b)(8). Journalist submits articles periodically; not integrated into production process; favors contractor status.Renumbered to (c)(5). Journalist writes for a digital news outlet from home and has no role in assigning, reviewing or timing articles. Working from home does not strongly indicate either status.Updated to reflect a digital newsroom; still favors contractor status.